Argentina Star Avoids Red Card Again as Debate Returns
Lionel Messi once again made headlines for his brilliance on the pitch.
The Argentine captain scored a stunning hat-trick as Argentina defeated Algeria 3-0 in their opening match of the 2026 FIFA World Cup.
The victory strengthened Argentina’s title defense and added another historic chapter to Messi’s legendary career.
However, despite the celebrations, a controversial incident involving Messi has sparked debate across the football world.
Table of Contents
The Challenge on Mandi
During the match, Messi appeared to step on Algeria defender Aïssa Mandi’s calf with his studs.
Many fans and pundits immediately questioned why the incident was not punished more severely.
In modern football, challenges involving studs making contact above the ankle are often reviewed carefully by VAR.
Depending on the force and intent, similar incidents have resulted in red cards in major competitions.
As a result, critics argue that Messi was fortunate to remain on the pitch. Had the referee deemed the challenge serious foul play, Argentina could have been reduced to ten men long before Messi completed his historic hat-trick.
An Old Controversy Resurfaces
Furthermore, the incident has revived memories of Argentina’s quarter-final clash against the Netherlands at the 2022 FIFA World Cup.
In that match, Messi deliberately handled the ball while attempting to stop a Dutch attack.
According to the Laws of the Game, the action was widely viewed as a clear yellow-card offense. Yet Messi was not booked for the handball.
The controversy became even greater because Messi later scored in the same match.
Had he received a yellow card for the handball, he would have accumulated enough bookings to miss the semi-final against Croatia.
Instead, he remained on the field, scored, and helped Argentina continue their march toward the World Cup trophy.
Is Messi Receiving Special Treatment?
Naturally, these incidents have led some football supporters to ask an uncomfortable question: Is Lionel Messi receiving special treatment from referees?
Supporters of this view point to the Netherlands handball incident and now the challenge on Mandi as examples of officials showing leniency toward one of football’s biggest stars.
On the other hand, Messi’s defenders argue that referees make controversial decisions in every major tournament.
They insist that mistakes are part of football and that there is no evidence of deliberate favoritism.
Moreover, many of the game’s greatest players, including Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, Diego Maradona, and Pelé, have all benefited from controversial decisions at different points in their careers.
The Debate Continues
What cannot be disputed is Messi’s performance against Algeria.
The 38-year-old produced a magnificent hat-trick, leading Argentina to a comfortable 3-0 victory and equaling Miroslav Klose’s World Cup scoring record.
Yet, while Argentina celebrates another Messi masterclass, the discussion surrounding the challenge on Mandi is unlikely to disappear anytime soon.
Whether it was a clear red card or simply an unfortunate collision will remain a matter of opinion.
Nevertheless, one question continues to divide football fans around the world:
If any other player had made the same challenge, would the referee have reached a different decision?
Follow more updates on Habanaija.com
Author: Sheriff Ogunremi
Sheriff is a versatile creative professional skilled in digital art, animation, and content design. He brings clarity and charm to every project, from visual storytelling to engaging community-focused content.
